Ram Puniyani
We have witnessed number of acts
of terror in India,
during last two decades. While those involved in the acts of terror have been
coming from individuals of different religions, the net outcome of the actions
of investigation agencies and police has been to arrest Muslim youth, to put
charges against them and in most cases to release them after the charges are
not proved on any ground. This pattern had a ‘mini-break’ for sometime after
the Malegaon
blast of 2008. The professional, unbiased and meticulous investigation of the Malegaon blast by the
then chief of Maharashtra ATS, Hemant Karkare came as a big step in getting to
the terrorists. Due to this; starting from Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur, Swami
Dayanand Pandey, Swami Aseemanand and many others belonging to the ideology of
Hindutva nationalism are currently cooling their heels in the jails.
Investigations into Malegaon
and many other blasts are showing the imprint of these Hindutva groups and
people. One thought that this major breakthrough into acts of investigation
will change the mind set of police authorities and they will overcome their
biases and do a more professional job in investigation into the acts of terror.
of terror in India,
during last two decades. While those involved in the acts of terror have been
coming from individuals of different religions, the net outcome of the actions
of investigation agencies and police has been to arrest Muslim youth, to put
charges against them and in most cases to release them after the charges are
not proved on any ground. This pattern had a ‘mini-break’ for sometime after
the Malegaon
blast of 2008. The professional, unbiased and meticulous investigation of the Malegaon blast by the
then chief of Maharashtra ATS, Hemant Karkare came as a big step in getting to
the terrorists. Due to this; starting from Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur, Swami
Dayanand Pandey, Swami Aseemanand and many others belonging to the ideology of
Hindutva nationalism are currently cooling their heels in the jails.
Investigations into Malegaon
and many other blasts are showing the imprint of these Hindutva groups and
people. One thought that this major breakthrough into acts of investigation
will change the mind set of police authorities and they will overcome their
biases and do a more professional job in investigation into the acts of terror.
Alas that was not to be and
guided by Pavlovian reflex, in a knee jerk fashion, police continues to repeat
its pattern of giving statements immediately after the acts of terror in which
the organizations like Indian Mujahedeen. Lashkar and others continue to be
being named without a thorough probe. This is followed by the usual arrests and
framing them. Recently first in the case of Hyderabad twin blasts on 21
February 2013 in which 17 people died and over hindered were injured. These
bombs were kept on a bicycle and Indian Mujahideen were blamed for this
dastardly act. Later in Bangalore
on 17th April a bomb exploded 300 meters from the BJP office. For this
blast a motorcycle was used. In this blast around 16 people were injured. It
was propagated that the blast took place near BJP office! As usual Indian
Mujahedeen were blamed. In this blast again there was an additional factor
about propaganda that blast took place near BJP office, when in reality the
blast was 300 meters away from the spot. Congress spokesperson Shakil Ahmad
said that this blast and the propaganda of its being near BJP office will
benefit BJP in the forthcoming elections, while another Congress spokesperson
and BJP countered the statement of Shakil Ahmad.
guided by Pavlovian reflex, in a knee jerk fashion, police continues to repeat
its pattern of giving statements immediately after the acts of terror in which
the organizations like Indian Mujahedeen. Lashkar and others continue to be
being named without a thorough probe. This is followed by the usual arrests and
framing them. Recently first in the case of Hyderabad twin blasts on 21
February 2013 in which 17 people died and over hindered were injured. These
bombs were kept on a bicycle and Indian Mujahideen were blamed for this
dastardly act. Later in Bangalore
on 17th April a bomb exploded 300 meters from the BJP office. For this
blast a motorcycle was used. In this blast around 16 people were injured. It
was propagated that the blast took place near BJP office! As usual Indian
Mujahedeen were blamed. In this blast again there was an additional factor
about propaganda that blast took place near BJP office, when in reality the
blast was 300 meters away from the spot. Congress spokesperson Shakil Ahmad
said that this blast and the propaganda of its being near BJP office will
benefit BJP in the forthcoming elections, while another Congress spokesperson
and BJP countered the statement of Shakil Ahmad.
In Bangalore blast, the preceding incidents are
very disturbing and revealing. Just ten days before the Bangalore blast, on sixth April in Kannur
(Kerala) a blast took place from the motorcycle and RSS swayamsevak A. V.
Dileep Kumar who was carrying four kilograms of explosives died. One recalls
that the RSS associates also got killed in blasts in Nanded, Kanpur and many other places. This Kannur
incident was underplayed and not much is known about the investigation so far
as such. It is interesting that police authorities who immediately named Indian
Mujahidin have been totally silent on the Hindutva connection of probable
terrorists, as by now the nation knows the involvement of Hindutva groups in
many acts of terror. The real loser of these biases held by authorities and
common people is the country as a whole. The real reason being that if we don’t
nab the real culprits and remain trapped in the usual prejudices and biases,
the real culprits will continue to carry on their nefarious work over and over
again.
very disturbing and revealing. Just ten days before the Bangalore blast, on sixth April in Kannur
(Kerala) a blast took place from the motorcycle and RSS swayamsevak A. V.
Dileep Kumar who was carrying four kilograms of explosives died. One recalls
that the RSS associates also got killed in blasts in Nanded, Kanpur and many other places. This Kannur
incident was underplayed and not much is known about the investigation so far
as such. It is interesting that police authorities who immediately named Indian
Mujahidin have been totally silent on the Hindutva connection of probable
terrorists, as by now the nation knows the involvement of Hindutva groups in
many acts of terror. The real loser of these biases held by authorities and
common people is the country as a whole. The real reason being that if we don’t
nab the real culprits and remain trapped in the usual prejudices and biases,
the real culprits will continue to carry on their nefarious work over and over
again.
As such apart from other thingson this trend of Muslim youth being arrested a good amount of documentation and
people’s investigation has been done by various human rights groups. ANHAD held
a people’s tribunal and published it report, ‘Scapegoats and Holy Cows’. Lately
a significant report by Jamia Teachers Solidarity Association led by Manisha
Sethi has published ‘Framed, Damned, and Acquitted’. This report in a
analytic way tells us the stereotypical manner of police investigation and
actions and the plight of those who were arrested particularly by the Delhi
Police Special Cell on charges of these youth being part of terrorist outfits.
In most of these cases they were acquitted by courts. This report as such
should have created awareness about the police methods and a pressure on police
to mend its ways. The report also points that the biased atmosphere has been
created as media is publishing the police version uncritically. This is in
contrast to the journalistic ethics where the official versions have to be
checked, cross checked and examined critically before publishing them. The
human rights groups also have been struggling for getting compensation to these
victims in good measure but to no avail so far. And then the question comes up
as to what about the police officers who are guilty of these acts of wrongful
investigation and implicating innocent youth, ruining their life in a serious
way? Should they not be punished?
The pattern of police reporting
is also very stereotypical and needs to be seriously criticized. The question
is what the senior leadership is doing in the face of findings of these
reports. Is it not important for the policy makers to take cognizance of such
important reports and respond to them in the form of policy change for the
investigation authorities? Amongst others another human rights group, Rihai
Manch from Uttar Pradesh is also campaigning on this issue and trying to get
the innocent youth released. UP Government had appointed a Nimesh Commission to
investigate these cases, but for reasons known to itself the government is not
releasing the report and is doing some patch work here and there.
While UP Government is dodging
over the issue of implicating the Muslim youth, one of its ministers is having
the taste of these biases in United States,
where he was detained at Boston.
While he is blaming Indian External Affairs Minister for this, he is forgetting
that these biases against Muslims are equally widespread and before him, people
of the stature of ex President Abdul Kalam and the celebrity like Shah Rukh
Khan have faced similar situations. Is it not an indication enough for the UP minister
to set his own house in order as for as the implication of Muslim youth in acts
of terror are concerned. The real worrying point of all these incidents is the
way biases against Muslims are becoming rooted more and more. What efforts are
needed to counter this stereotypical nature of understanding security agencies
and perceptions at popular level needs a serious course correction on urgent
basis.
Leave a Reply