CHARVAKA DESK

  • Modi’s-Abusing History for Political Mileage

    Ram Puniyani The Politics of Modi’ parent organisation RSS is based on distortion of history, medieval history in particular. to begin with the projection of kings through the prism of religion, to demonise Muslim kings based on distortions and falsehoods of History, and then in turn spreading hatred against Muslims of today has been the…

  • Love Jihad: From Illusory Slogan to Potent Weapon

    Ram Puniyani The country is yet to recover from the aftermath of Muzaffranagar violence (October 2013). This violence was engineered over a period of time in the areas of Western UP, where Jats and Muslims had thick social interaction, despite belonging to different economic strata. Communal violence has been instigated, engineered earlier on various issues…

  • Engels, Dialectics and Buddhism

    Ramkrishna Bhattacharya The book that has come down to us under the title Dialectics of Naure is strictly speaking not a book but an edited version of four folders containing miscellaneous notes and jottings left unfinished by their author, Frederick Engles. The material was never published in Engles’s life time although parts of it were…

  • Explained Series: Books and Exhibition on Communalism Explained and Terrorism Explained

    Ram Puniyani Friends, Violence under the garb of religion has been the major expression of the politics in current times. Sharad Sharma, and myself are working on ‘Explained Series’. The aim of the series is to present the phenomenon in the form of graphic presentations, Comic Books. Two books in this series are already out…

  • The Healing Gashes of the Oracle

    This article deconstructs the miracle claim of self-wounding and instant healing using a blunt knife. By combining iron(III) ions on the skin with thiocyanate or salicylate reagents on the blade, a performer generates blood-red coordination complexes. The water-soluble color is easily wiped away, proving the “blood” is inorganic chemistry, not supernatural immunity.

  • Catching a Thief by Sorcery

    A self-styled tantrik claims to identify thieves using a sacred stick planted in a dark room. After a frightening fire ritual, suspects enter alone to touch the stick. The top is secretly smeared with asafoetida. Innocent suspects touch it, while a superstitious thief avoids contact out of fear, revealing themselves through odorless fingers.

  • Formal versus Substantive Justice: Shinde’s Letter on Harassment of innocent Muslims

    Ram Puniyani In his letter to all the Chief Ministers Sushil Kumar Shinde’s Centre’s Home Minster (30, 09, 2013), wrote that Government has been receiving complaints of harassment of innocent Muslim youth by Law enforcement agencies. He asked the state authorities to ensure that no innocent Muslim youth should be arrested or wrongfully detained in…

  • “I Would Be Happy To See a Real Miracle Before I Die”:

    In this concluding afterword to Volume 1, B. Premanand highlights how unscrupulous godmen exploit superstitions and evade legal action despite robust Indian laws. He emphasizes the necessity of cultivating a scientific temper, details his lifetime search for authentic paranormal phenomena, and outlines Abraham T. Kovoor’s famous One-Lakh Rupee Paranormal Challenge.

  • All India Anti-Superstition Bill: Letter from Prabhakar Nanawaty

    We reproduce an email received from Mr. Prabhakar Nanawathy, Editor of “Thought & Action”, the organ of Andhashradda Nirmoolan Samiti (ANiS, founded by Dr Narendra Dabholkar), which was instrumental in getting the anti-superstition bill passed by the Maharashtra Assembly. The Samiti is now planning to have a similar bill passed by our Parliament. You may…

  • Our Pledge to Kashmir

    Jawaharlal Nehru I must express my gratitude to the many hon. Members who, in the course of this debate, have spoken generously about the policy that the Government has pursued in regard to the State of Jammu and Kashmir. While we have had an abundance of generous acknowledgement of our policy, we have had criticism…

  • Polarization with a difference: Muzaffarnagar Violence

    Ram Puniyani Communal violence has been the bane of Indian society, more so from last three decades. One can see its coming up prominently from 1893 to begin with and then it went through different phases. It became stronger after 1937, peaked in 1946 and then the post partition holocaust shattered the lives of lakhs…

  • Are Goan Catholics Culturally Hindu?

    Ram Puniyani Identity issues are at the fore in current times. Those basing their politics on the identity issues have lot of assertions about who the ‘others’ are. There is a constant ongoing attempt to assimilate them in the umbrella of their religion and culture. Current times, where religious nationalism dominates, the scene is that…

  • Kashmir: Let the People Decide

    Jawaharlal Nehru The house will remember that a few days ago I made a fairly lengthy statement in this House about the affairs of Jammu and Kashmir State. I do not propose to weary the House by a repetition of what I said then. But at this stage, I should like to emphasize certain aspects…

  • Business of Faith

    Ram Puniyani Our society has seen severe turmoil’s in the name of religion during last three decades in particular. While on one side we see that issues related to religion’s identity are trying to occupy the center stage, we also are witnessing the emergence of thousands of self proclaimed ‘Godmen’, supposed to be having divine…

  • Who Killed Narendra Dabholkar?

    Ram Puniyani The brutal killing of Dr. Narendra Dabholkar (20th August 2013) is a big jolt to the social movement against blind faith and superstitions. During last few decades the tendency for promotion of rational thought parallel to social change came up as Popular Science movement. In Maharashtra it took shape in the form of a movement, Andh Shraddha Nirmoolan…

  • Modi Phenomenon: an Attack on Indian Democracy

    Ram Puniyani Currently (August 2013) Narendra Modi is trying to dominate the media, print social and TV through his carefully constructed propaganda machinery and his potential of being nominated as the BJP’s Prime Ministerial candidate by RSS-BJP. Modi has openly used the words like puppies dying under the car wheel, while referring to the victims…

  • Jawaharlal Nehru: Three Letters on Ayodhya

    Jawaharlal Nehru To GB Pant New Delhi April 17, 1950 My dear Pantji, Thank you for your letter about Shahjahanpur. I am quite sure that your Government has taken strong and effective action during these recent troubles in the U.P. I am glad to learn that as a result of that action as well as…

  • Resist Anti-Scientific Temper Forces
    A Statement by Intellectuals & Activists

    Joint Statement • 20 August 2013 Statement on the Brutal Murder of Dr. Narendra Dabholkar We the scientist, rationalists, educators and intellectuals of the country learnt with shock and anger the brutal and inhuman murder of Dr Narendra Dabholkar. This murder is part of the series of attacks that have been perpetrated by anti scientific…

  • Materialist Philosophy in Chāndogya Upaniṣad

    As one of the principal Upaniṣads, the text (Chāndogya Upaniṣad) is usually viewed as pre-Buddha, and hence, might have belonged to c. seventh century BC. Since in the extract quoted here we have the earliest reference to a view identifying the body with the self, which is reminiscent of one of the typical tenets of…

  • Kandhamal Violence -5 Years Later

    Ram Puniyani This August 25, 2013, it will be five years, since the biggest anti Christian, violence, biggest communal violence in the Adivisi area, will complete five years. What has been the plight of the victims of the violence after this ghastly tragedy? What is the state of justice to the victim? Kandhamal violence began…

  • The Spirit of Science

    Jawaharlal Nehru In the course of less than four months, we have put up, declared open or are going to declare open three national laboratories. I suppose before this year is out some more national laboratories will also be started. This is a great venture testifying to the faith which our scientists and, I hope,…

  • Religion, Atheism and Secularism

    Ram Puniyani Last three decades have seen an unprecedented presence of religion in social and political space. Somewhere the acts of terror, somewhere communal violence and somewhere the political influence of religious right on society and political processes, all these phenomenon have overshadowed the deeper inequities in the society, the aspirations of people for dignity…

  • Evil, Freedom, Suffering and Sport

    AN Moorthy Rao Let us consider how some people explain the existence of evil: “God bestowed on man, right at the time of creation, all the powers and qualities that man needed. He does not want man to be a puppet in His hands. He has, therefore, given man freedom of will. Man is free…

  • The Miracle of the Sacred Eagles

    At Thirukazhukundram, wild eagles’ daily midday visits were hailed as divine miracles. B. Premanand reported the birds were addicted to opium-laced food. Science demonstrates that regular feeding schedules, food-anticipatory activity, and thermal soaring explain this behavior, while India’s catastrophic diclofenac-driven vulture decline explains why the visits eventually ceased.