Sex, Lies and Religion

Reason & Rights: Sex, Lies and Religion — Charvaka.net
Reason & Rights
Deconstructing the Myth of Celibacy, Clerical Hypocrisy, and Moral Double Standards Across Faiths

It has hit the headlines again—the holy men indulging in not-so-holy activities! Well, screaming headlines and bordering-on-pornography video footage for the sensation-mongering media have brought to the fore what religion is about: sex! If one were to look for the common factor between jihadis, swamis, and the priests of the Roman Catholic Church, it could be only one—obsession with sex.

As it is said, one craves more for what one has been deprived of, and sex is the one which has been denied to all these categories. It is not that such behavior does not occur between followers of other religions in similar circumstances, but their number is significantly less and hence does not hit the headlines as often. However, some such have been reported among Jains and Buddhists too.

The behavior of Nithyananda, whose tapes have been played ad nauseam on some of the TV channels, has been justified as consensual sex, and that being caught on video has been said to be an invasion of his privacy. The saffron-robed pimp who has been caught in Delhi can get away with a lack of evidence. But more despicable is the act of the Roman Catholic clergy who have traumatized innocent children and probably scarred their psyche for life. No number of apologies from the Vatican can remove this trauma from the minds of these children who have been betrayed by the very guardians of the religion whose deity was supposed to be watching over and protecting children! Well, that brings us to sex and the jihadis—what do they have in common? If one recalls, most of the jihadis are young boys brainwashed into sacrificing their lives for a trip to heaven where they can indulge in carnal delights to their heart’s content with dozens of virgins who will remain in that state regardless of the number of times they indulge in sex!

Well, why do religions have this obsession about sex and prescribe celibacy for their so-called enlightened? Many of the so-called preachers have to lead very austere lives—with exceptions, of course! If you take the Roman Catholic clergy, the only delights that are forbidden to them are that of indulging in sex! They can enjoy all other luxuries in the open, while the forbidden one could be indulged in secretly or with unsuspecting children. There is a saying: “If you want gay nights and good dinners, dine with saints and bed with sinners!” The Roman Catholic Church believes in prescribing abstinence in only one department. The same thing is applicable to many of the so-called Swamijis and Jagadgurus of the religious establishments in our country. The jewelry on their person would put to shame the brides of the wealthiest of our land. All this is excused as the desire of the devotees. Probably the same could be the excuse for indulgence in sex too. If a devotee desires the same, what is wrong with fulfilling that, would run the argument of the defenders of these swamijis!

Not to be left out of the debate on the moral degradation of the saffron-robed, the squeaky-voiced one who teaches people to breathe and the one who has made millions by indulging in contortions and thumbing his nose at people joined the debate by demanding the strictest of punishments for those who call themselves swamis and indulge in such immoral activities. What about those who call themselves that and indulge in land grabbing, extortion, and such rackets? What about those who promise cures for everything under the sun without a shred of evidence to support their claims? They would naturally be silent on these issues, as these are precisely the things in which they indulge!

Why should “celibacy” be prescribed for these people? One argument of the saffron brigade would be that suppression of the sexual urge leads to the diversion of this energy to other channels, and this is supposed to be the reason for the extraordinary shine on their faces and the rest of the body. The Roman Catholic Church may talk about original sin and the need to be kept away from it. There are quite a few cults who prescribe celibacy for their followers. One young lady who was a follower of such a cult called Brahma Kumaris Ishwariya Vidyalaya had attended one of our five-day workshops for miracle exposure. After tolerating her presence for a few days, I asked her a question about Brahmacharya prescribed by her cult. She replied that it would lead one closer to God, etc., as brainwashed by her cult. I had to ask her where she would have been if her parents were celibate? She had no reply, but mumbled vaguely. Then I asked her whether her cult forbids breathing, eating, etc. Her reply was in the negative. In that case, why should they forbid only one biological activity, that too which is very much needed for the continuance of the race? Of course, my pointed questions resulted in her absence from the program from the very next day. She was a very junior activist of that cult. The more well-known people like the Nobel Peace Prize aspirant squeaky-voice and the contortionist have more convoluted excuses for celibacy and justify it by various “reasons.” This abstinence theory is more of a Christian import, as it is the biblical concept of the “original sin” of Eve that has labeled reproductive activity as a curse of God! This idea of abstinence from sex or Brahmacharya was also promoted by Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi as one of the most desirable of virtues, probably induced by the guilt in his mind that he was indulging in that when his father had died.

Well, this leads us to the question of the sexual indulgences of the so-called renunciates. Is it illegal? Well, if seen from a legal point of view, sexual intercourse between two consenting adults of the same or different genders is not a crime. There are laws on adultery applicable if the woman indulging in heterosexual activity is married, but if she is not, then it cannot be called anything illegal. However, one has to note that these sections on adultery are gender-specific—they are applicable to the woman only! It does not matter if the man is married! The Supreme Court has come to this same conclusion about the cases filed against an actor in Tamil Nadu for advocating premarital sex. It may be recalled that cases had been filed against this lady for making a public statement to that effect a few years back. There had been demonstrations by women’s groups and a number of cases filed against her all over Tamil Nadu just to harass her. The judgment in her special leave petition filed at the Supreme Court had quashed all these cases and had also pronounced that sexual activity between consenting adults cannot be construed as a criminal offense. We have to see what the Dals and Senas of our district have to say about it. Their view is that even going together or speaking to each other in a public place is an offense, and the police act like agents of these people. This sense of outrage is even more when the male belongs to another community and the female is a Hindu!

We do agree that the clergy of all religions are human like all of us. If they are, then it would behoove them to act like humans and not like superhumans. Let them give up their hypocrisy about these things and stop calling themselves by fancy names and fancier titles. They should not demand or get any exemptions from any laws of the land and get facilities at subsidized rates or free, and land at throwaway prices. Many times they are the repositories of the ill-gotten wealth of corrupt politicians, since they are exempt from tax raids. Let them be treated exactly like us ordinary mortals, and then we shall agree that they too can indulge in those activities in which we do! When this is the case, women shall treat them like they do other males; no one will think that children are safe with them. If all these happen, I am sure that their robes shall lose their charms and they will be categorized as ordinary mortals that we are. The shine on their faces due to the austerities that they allegedly practice will disappear, and from Brahmacharis they will become sansaris like all of us!

Prof. Narendra Nayak — Author Profile
Prof. Narendra Nayak

Prof. Narendra Nayak

Prof. Narendra Nayak is the President of the Federation of Indian Rationalist Associations (FIRA) and a prominent rationalist campaigner.

View Full Biographical Profile

Prof. Narendra Nayak founded the Dakshina Kannada Rationalist Association in 1976 and the NGO Aid Without Religion in July 2011. A dedicated educator and activist, he travels extensively across India and internationally, having conducted over 3,500 workshops and demonstrations to promote scientific temper and train the public in debunking godmen and exposing fraudulent miracle-mongers.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *